
When the earnest Lowlanders, bent on giving surnames to Highlanders who had no surnames and spoke little English, realized the difficulty of their task, they must soon have discovered that the way to find out the 'name' of a Highlander was to question him about his chief. The clansmen had listened to the bards reciting clan genealogy from their earliest childhood, back to the first man to settle on the land (and beyond.) Thus a MacKinnon might say that his chief was the son of Fingon (or Findanus) or he might say that he was the son of Alpin (son meaning "race of"), for the early MacKinnon chiefs were all known as So-and-so of the House of Findanus (who gave the clan his name) who was of the House of Alpin (who gave the clan their lands).
Early histories once tended to dismiss the Sìol Alpin as an imagined piece of boastfulness by old clans, and without claim. The reason for this is quite obvious: researchers have searched the clan histories for the Sìol Alpin and found no evidence of the claim. They tried to compare it to Clan Chattan, another great confederation, and could find no similarity. Based on this, many of them dismissed Sìol Alpin altogether.
Diagram of suggested lines of descent:
Alpin, first king of Scots and Picts
I I I
King Kenneth King Donald Dungal
I I
King Constantine the Abbott Girig mac Dungal
MacNab I
I
Guarie Findaus Gregor "the Great"
I I I
MacQuarrie MacKinnon MacGregor
I I
MacFie Clan Grant & MacAulay
The royal House of Alpin, which lasted down to the reign of Malcolm II (1005-1034) gave widely separated grants of land to the younger sons of the family, keeping them well separated. This old and effective policy of divide and rule prevented the younger sons and their descendants from combining to put one of their number in place of the current ruler. Only a fool allowed younger sons and cousins to congregate together.
Because of this policy the seven clans were widely scattered: Three are Hebridean and lived on islands, three are west Highland, and one other, the Grants, settled in the northeast side of Scotland. According to this arrangement:
* The original MacKinnon lands were in Mull and from here they spread to Arran and Skye.
* Grant lands were in Strathspey and Glenmoriston.
* MacNab lands were in Perthshire on the western shore of Loch Tay.
* MacAulays had their seat at Ardincaple in Dumbartonshire.
* MacFies held lands in Colonsay.
* MacQuarries had lands in Mull near the MacKinnons, also the island of Ulva, west of Mull.
* MacGregors had many possessions, their early principal seat being Glenorchy.
Clan Gregor also had estates at Glenstrae, Glenlyon, Glengyle, Glenlochy and Balquhidder,
most of which was taken by the ever ambitious and predatory lords of Campbell.
The clans of the Sìol Alpin share a common plant badge, the Scots Pine. The MacFies and the MacKinnons (and present day MacAlpines) have the same Alpin war cry of Cuimhnich Bas Alpein meaning "Remember the death of King Alpin." The MacGregors were more boastful, adopting as their motto 'S rioghal mo dhream which means "Royal Is My Race." However, they are not alone in royal ties, nor are the rest of the Sìol Alpin clans.
